[Jewish] [Mindful Torah] Commentary on Parshat Aharei Mot-Kedoshim

[Rabbi Steven Nathan]

This week we read the double portion/parashah of Aharei Mot-Kedoshim
(Vayikra/Leviticus 16:1-20). These two portions contain numerous
mitzvot/commandments, some of which make sense to us today, some which
don't, and some which are totally antithetical to what we view as
righteousness and justice. This includes the "holiness code" in chapter
19 which includes the commandment "you shall be holy, for I, the
Eternal your God, am holy" as well as "you shall love your fellow human
being as yourself." This section is viewed by our tradition as the
center of the Torah. Indeed, it is actually located almost at the
center of the scroll itself. And yet, much of what is found in this
parashah is still perplexing to me. Some of it is abhorrent.

I was thinking about this when I read R. Levi Yitzhak of Berditchev's
19th century commentary on a verse from the parashah: "You shall
observe My statutes and My laws which, if a person do them, that person
shall live by them; I am the Eternal" (Leviticus 18:5). In the rabbinic
tradition, the hukkim (statutes) are viewed as commandments that have
no apparent rational reason, while the
mishpatim (laws) are those that have an apparent rational reason. The
prohibition against murder is one of the mishpatim. The prohibition
against mixing linen and wool in garments or eating meat and milk
together are among the hukkim.

In his interpretation, Levi Yitzhak states that the observance of
the "irrational" hukkim "purifies" a person's mind so that s/he can
then truly understand the meaning of the mishpatim, or "rational"
commandments. By looking at the commandments this way, Levi Yitzhak
says that a person then come to "live by them," meaning that s/he
will "come to understand that they are the source of
his/her vitality."

In his analysis of this text, R. David Blumenthal discusses how the
essence of this teaching is that all of the mitzvot/commandments are
part of God's plan and God's will. It doesn't matter whether or not
they have an apparent reason. Furthermore, it is being subservient to
God's will that is at the core of
observance and this too must guide us through the path of mitzvot.

Looking at all of these comments together it would seem that Levi
Yitzhak is trying to tell us that the observance of the 'irrational'
mitzvot somehow purifies or clears out our minds so that we can then
view the 'rational' mitzvot in a new light. This new light allows us to
realize that the "rationality" of
these mitzvot is inconsequential. What is consequential is that the
mitzvot are the tools by which we create holy lives for ourselves and
through which we connect ourselves to God. All the mitzvot are as one
and their purpose is one - connection with the Divine and the Divine
will.

Divine will is something with which many of us - myself included -
struggle. I admit that I try to do God's will in my life, even though I
am uncertain what that means. In the broadest sense, it means to do
those things that make the world a better place. God's will also means
doing those things that make us feel connected to God and, beyond that,
help us to realize that we are all a part of God and God is a part of
us.

We don't need to analyze or try discover the hidden meaing behind the
mitzvah "do not curse the deaf nor put a stumbling block before the
blind" (also found in this parashah). It is quite obvious why this is
holy behavior. But Levi Yitzhak instead focuses how performing the
irrational mitzvot can add to our understanding of the rational ones
and heighten our sense of holiness.

Following his logic, then the irrational can become rational in our
minds. We may argue about the reasons behind the laws of keeping
kosher. There are many theories about the rationale behind them. And
yet in the end, from the Torah's point of view, what matters is that
they are about maintaining holiness when eating. If one accepts and
abosorbs that point of view then the irrational act of separating
dishes becomes the rational act of extending that idea of holy eating
to every aspect of the meal, even down to the silverware we use.

However, there are some mitzvot that are neither rational nor
irrational, even though the rabbis of old may have classified them as
such. These mitzvot are not only anachronistic, as are so many mitzvot,
but they are, as I wrote above, abhorrent. Perhaps they were not
abhorrent in their original context, but they are today.

The most obvious is the prohibition of male homosexuality. "Do not lie
with a man as with a woman" may have made sense in the context of the
times and in terms of the other commandments that surround it in the
Torah. But I do not want to engage in that analysis right now. There
are enough who have done that before me. But what makes this text
abhorrent to me is how it has been used throughout the centuries to
persecute, ostracize and kill gay men and lesbians, as well as bisexual
and transgender folk, in the name of God. When it comes down to the
tachlis, practical application, of this verse I ultimately don't care
about the original context or intention. What I care about is how it
has been used and what it has come to mean to so many.

I realize that there are orthodox gay men who still abide by this verse
in terms of limiting the types of sexual activity in which they will
engage. And I am in no way chastizing them or their choices. They are
making a mindful choice to live a life based on the mitzvot that they
believe come directly from God, even when they are difficult and
painful ones. This is one of those mitzvot.

However, I am chastizing those who have mindlessly used this verse, and
others, to sanction hatred and bigotry in our world. Just as Biblical
verses were used to condone the enslavement of Africans in the United
States, this verse has been used for its own kind of enslavement and
abuse of human beings. That is why I may read it in synagogue, for it
is part of the Torah, but, I read it with the understanding that it may
be part of the traditions, but it is no longer for me.

What does any of this have to do with mindfulness? Perhaps nothing. Or
perhaps, what I am ultimately saying is that looking at this text, and
others, with equanimity may enable me to let go of the disdain and
anger that I feel when I read it now, even though I will still reject
it.

In addition, I believe that it is the inability to look at the text
this way, and the insertion of ego and judgmental thinking into the
reading of the text, that has caused people to use it to legitimize
hateful and ultimately unholy behavior. This use of the text is
antithetical to the mindful principals of non-judgmental awareness,
equanimity and compassion.

In closing, I must admit that this is a very personal issue for me, and
so perhaps I have not been as non-judgmental or approached it with as
much equanimity as I should have been. But that is my truth in this
moment. However, in the end, I feel that, just as the practice
of "irrational" mitzvot can enhance the rational ones, so too can the
rejection of those which I - and others - can no longer accept as a
mitzvah at all that also frees us to practice the others with a great
sense of meaning and as a way to help us become more aware of the
Divine within us and which connects us to each other and the world.

Shabbat Shalom.

--
Posted By Rabbi Steven Nathan to Mindful Torah at 4/23/2010 04:44:00 PM
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.hampshire.edu/pipermail/jewish/attachments/20100423/3032c91a/attachment.htm>